Scripted Theatre was one of Casey's first performance outlets. Skills such as embodying a character, memorizing lines, and taking direction have served him well from high school, college, and beyond. Some credits of his hard work performing scripted pieces are as follows: 

- Participant in the MSHSL State Competitive Speech Tournament withing Humorous Interpretation, 2009

- Recipient of the Patricia Troy Performing Arts Scholarship, 2009

- ACTF Nomination for the Irene Ryan Scholarship for 'As You Like It', 2010

- Participant in the Kennedy Center American College Theatre Festival, 2011

Casey has performed in classical pieces such as Shakespeare's 'As You Like It', musicals such as, 'Cabaret', and locally written shows like 'Variety Show Death Match'.